On appeals courts, where judges typically rule in groups, collaboration is the rule. But trial judges are seen as solitary actors, the captains of their courtrooms, answerable only to a higher court. That is what makes a trial judge calling another for advice seem unusual to outsiders....I couldn't find anything in the article about what was "game-show-like," but I think we're just supposed to remember that on the old show "Who Wants to Be a Millionaire," contestants were allowed 3 "lifelines," one of which was "phone a friend." So... calling a colleague for help with a question you find hard could thus be "game-show-like."
Judge Ronnie Abrams, a former prosecutor appointed to the bench in 2012, said she had been �at both ends� of such calls. As a judge, she said, �you can�t talk about your job to too many people, and so it�s nice to use the kind of experience and perspective of your colleagues when appropriate.�
Tuesday, May 19, 2015
Federal district court judges call each other up when they're "puzzled by legal questions" and they've "been on the receiving end of the game-show-like call for help."
The NYT reports based on interviews with "a dozen judges in Manhattan�s Federal District Court."
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment